Rikk Watts and Critical Realism: Reading Genesis 1

Rikk Watts' article "Making Sense of Genesis 1" for the American Scientific Affliation is a great example of critical realist biblical interpretation in the strain following Bernard Lonergan. He gives a great summary of Michael Polanyi's notion of tacit knowledge (a notion closely related to Lonergan's horizon) and Bernard Lonergan's understanding of the process of coming to know (moving from questions to insight and finally to judgment). He says,


"Michael Polanyi reminded us that taking a great many things on trust is the essential first step to knowledge, even and perhaps especially in that highest and holiest of all modern callings, science. All of us, Christians and scientists together, simply have to take a great deal on trust, to assume much, if we are ever to get started on the path to knowing. The saying is sure, without assuming something no one shall know anything. But having said that, it is important regularly to reassess those assumptions in the light of our growing knowledge and in doing so to recognize that truth in this kind of historical and literary endeavour is much more a matter of coherence than of certainty. Bernard Lonergan rightly understood that the first step in knowing was to pay attention to all of the data, then to apply our intelligence in seeking to understand, and finally to use our reason to judge between hypotheses."

The article itself is a great example of that process in action. Check it out by following the link above.